The Halloween Book Club 2026 Reading List

This post contains affiliate links. See my disclaimer.

The Halloween Book Club has been resurrected — and this year, we are reading monthly. That's right. Nine books. Nine months.

After some time away, I wanted to come back with something that felt really intentional and exciting, and I am genuinely so proud of this list.

There's gothic atmosphere, folk horror, psychological dread, a Bram Stoker Award-winning indie novella, two perfectly placed classics, and a Victorian ghost story that was basically made to be read in December by candlelight.

Whether you're a returning member of The Halloween Book Club or you're joining us for the first time, I hope this list makes you want to clear your shelves and dive in.

Let's take a look at everything we're reading in 2026.


How The Halloween Book Club Works

The Halloween Book Club lives as a Facebook group — a community of 5,200+ Halloween lovers and horror readers from all over the world.

Here's how each month runs:

  • The 1st of the month: A book reminder post goes up with everything you need to know: what we're reading, what it's about, and where to find it.

  • The Friday before Week 3: A discussion reminder goes up so you can pace your reading and know what's coming.

  • Week 3, Monday through Wednesday: Discussion questions drop one per day. Answer one, answer all, or just read what everyone else thinks.

  • Week 3, Thursday: Haunted Scale rating day. We score every book across five spooky categories and tally up the group's verdict. 💀

One important thing to know: you are never required to read anything. Skip a month if a book doesn't call to you. Join the discussion halfway through. Come back to a thread weeks later because life happened — we'll still be there. The only requirement is a love of all things spooky.


2026 Halloween Book Club Reading List

April | “The Hacienda” by Isabel Cañas

We're kicking off the year with one of my most anticipated reads, and I think it's going to be a perfect first book for this new chapter of the club.

“The Hacienda” is set in 1820s Mexico, just after the War of Independence. Beatriz is in a desperate situation — newly married to a man she barely knows, far from everything familiar, and moving into his crumbling hacienda in the countryside. From the moment she arrives, something feels deeply wrong. The walls seem to breathe. The darkness lingers past when it should. Servants whisper and avoid certain rooms. And whatever evil has taken root in that house has been there for a very long time.

Isabel Cañas writes with such lush, immersive atmosphere — this book pulls you in and doesn't let go. It's a haunted house story at its core, but it's also about a woman using every resource available to her to survive in a world designed to keep her powerless. It was nominated for a Bram Stoker Award, praised by The New York Times and The Washington Post, and it is exactly the kind of read I want to open a new year of book club with.

Fair heads up: “The Hacienda” has a historical setting, but don't let that put you off if that's not usually your thing. The horror is very much front and center, and Cañas wears her history lightly. This one is about ghosts, not history lessons. GET A COPY

May | “A Head Full of Ghosts” by Paul Tremblay

If you've ever watched a paranormal reality TV show and wondered whether any of it was real, this book is going to get under your skin in a very specific way.

“A Head Full of Ghosts” follows the Barrett family — a struggling household that agrees to let a reality TV crew document the alleged demonic possession of their teenage daughter, Marjorie. The story is told years later by Merry, the younger sister who witnessed everything as an eight-year-old, in an interview with a writer researching the case. Was Marjorie possessed? Was she mentally ill? Was the whole thing a desperate bid for money and attention? Paul Tremblay never fully answers that question, and that is exactly the point.

This is one of the most talked-about horror novels of the last decade for good reason. It's layered and meta — there's a blogger character whose commentary runs parallel to the story and adds a whole extra dimension of unreliability — and it is genuinely, deeply unsettling in a way that doesn't rely on jump scares or gore. It relies on doubt. Stephen King called it "one of the most frightening books I've read in years." It won the Bram Stoker Award. And I promise you, your book club discussion is going to be one of the best ones we have all year.

Come prepared to argue. Lovingly. GET A COPY

June | “The Only Good Indians” by Stephen Graham Jones

I want to be upfront with you: this is the most intense book on our list. But it is also, arguably, the most important one — and one of the finest horror novels written in the last twenty years.

“The Only Good Indians” follows four Blackfoot men — Lewis, Gabe, Cass, and Ricky — who were friends growing up on the reservation and who made a terrible decision together on a hunting trip years ago. They've scattered since then, built their lives, tried to move on. But something ancient and deeply, righteously furious hasn't forgotten what they did. And now it's coming for them.

Stephen Graham Jones is one of the most celebrated voices in contemporary horror, and this book shows exactly why. It's visceral and literary at the same time — the kind of horror that hits you in the gut and then makes you think. It's rooted in Blackfoot culture and told with an insider's specificity that makes it feel completely unlike anything else in the genre. It was named one of the best books of 2020 by publications across the board, and readers consistently describe it as one of those books that stays with you long after you've finished.

Content note: this one has some intense scenes of violence. If you've read Stephen Graham Jones before, you know what to expect. If you haven't, just know it earns every scare. GET A COPY

July | “Plain Bad Heroines” by Emily M. Danforth

July is our longest read of the year, and I chose it deliberately for the summer month when you might have a little more time and space to sink into something big and ambitious. “Plain Bad Heroines” absolutely rewards the investment.

The novel operates on two timelines. In 1902, two girls at a New England boarding school called Brookhants start a secret literary society devoted to a scandalous author — and then people start dying in strange, horrible ways. In the present day, a horror film is being made about the Brookhants curse, with a cast and crew who are about to discover that the past isn't as finished with that place as anyone would like.

What makes this book extraordinary is how fully realized both timelines are. The 1902 sections have this rich, dark, gothic quality — yellow jackets, cursed meadows, doomed love affairs — and the contemporary sections crackle with meta-awareness and dark humor. It's a queer horror novel, a dark academia novel, a gothic novel, and a story about stories. Emily Danforth builds something genuinely unusual here and sees it all the way through.

It's long. It asks something of you. It is absolutely worth it. GET A COPY

August | “We Have Always Lived in the Castle” by Shirley Jackson ⭐ Classic Pick

Our first classic of the year, and one I have been wanting to bring to this club for a long time.

If you read “The Haunting of Hill House” with us back in 2018, you know what Shirley Jackson is capable of. But “We Have Always Lived in the Castle” is a completely different kind of book — quieter, stranger, and in some ways even more unsettling than “Hill House.” Where that novel builds to horror, this one simply lives inside it from page one, so naturally you almost don't notice.

Merricat Blackwood lives with her sister Constance on their family estate, shunned by the village, tending her rituals, and keeping a fierce, loving watch over the small world they've built together. Most of their family is dead. The village knows it. Nobody talks about why. And Merricat would like very much for things to stay exactly as they are.

Merricat is one of the most unforgettable narrators in all of American literature. She is strange and funny and oddly comforting and genuinely frightening, sometimes all in the same paragraph. This is a book under 150 pages that will leave an impression that lasts for years. A perfect late summer read. GET A COPY

September | “The Little Stranger” by Sarah Waters

As the air starts to turn and September arrives, I wanted something slow and creeping and literary — the kind of horror that settles into your bones gradually rather than hitting you all at once. “The Little Stranger” is exactly that.

Set in postwar England in the late 1940s, the novel follows Dr. Faraday, a country doctor called to treat the inhabitants of Hundreds Hall — a once-grand manor house that is slowly, quietly falling apart. The family living there is the last of their line: a widowed mother, a nervous son, and a daughter trying to hold everything together. As Faraday becomes more involved with the household, strange things begin to happen. Things that don't have easy explanations. Things the house seems to want.

Sarah Waters is a literary novelist working in the horror tradition, which means this book is exceptionally well-written and deliberately, gloriously ambiguous. What's happening at Hundreds Hall? Is it supernatural? Is it psychological? Is it the house, or is it one of its inhabitants, or is it the doctor himself? The novel never tells you outright, and that's what makes the discussion so rich. I have a feeling September is going to be one of our best conversation months of the year. GET A COPY

October | “Dark Harvest” by Norman Partridge
👻 Indie Pick

October's pick is something a little special — and I could not be more excited about it.

“Dark Harvest” was originally published in 2006 by Cemetery Dance Publications, one of the most beloved and respected indie horror presses in existence. Norman Partridge has been a cornerstone of the indie horror world since the early nineties, and this novella is widely considered his masterpiece. It won the Bram Stoker Award. Stephen King loves it. And it is, without question, the most perfectly Halloween book I have ever encountered.

Here's the premise: every Halloween night in a small Midwestern town, a creature called the October Boy rises from the cornfields. He has a jack-o'-lantern for a head, a butcher knife in his hand, and a candy heart beating in his chest. The teenage boys of the town are sent out to hunt him down — and whoever kills him before midnight wins a ticket out of this dead-end place forever. But this year, one boy is going to discover the terrible truth behind everything the town has built its traditions upon.

It is under 200 pages. You can read it in one sitting on Halloween night. I'm not saying you should plan your entire October around doing exactly that — but I'm also not not saying that.

Choosing an indie press book for October felt right on every level. This is a community that loves Halloween, loves books, and loves supporting small businesses — and Cemetery Dance is exactly that. A small press run by passionate people who have dedicated themselves to the best in horror fiction for more than 30 years. GET A COPY

November | “A House With Good Bones” by T. Kingfisher

After the intensity of October, November's pick offers something a little different — eerie and propulsive, yes, but with a dark streak of wit that keeps things from getting too heavy. It's the perfect gear shift for the month after Halloween.

Sam is a archaeoentomologist — a bug scientist — who comes home to visit her mother and immediately notices something is off. Her mother seems different. Quieter. Nervous in a way she's never been before. The house has changed too — roses everywhere, an unsettling tidiness, a feeling that something is being carefully maintained and equally carefully hidden. And the more Sam digs into what's wrong, the more she realizes that whatever it is goes back much further than her mother. It goes back to her grandmother. And it lives in the garden.

T. Kingfisher is one of the most exciting voices in modern horror, and “A House With Good Bones” is a great entry point if you haven't read her before. It's smart, it's funny in that dark way that makes you laugh and then feel slightly unsettled by the fact that you laughed, and it builds to something genuinely creepy. Cozy enough for a November evening. Unsettling enough to keep the spooky season alive well past Halloween. GET A COPY

December | “The Turn of the Screw” by Henry James
⭐ Classic Pick

December is busy for everyone, so our final read of the year is a short one — and it is perfect.

“The Turn of the Screw” is Henry James's 1898 novella about a young governess who arrives at a remote English country estate to care for two children, Miles and Flora, who are described as unnervingly, almost supernaturally perfect. Then she begins to see figures on the grounds. A man on a tower. A woman by the lake. Figures who, she comes to believe, are the ghosts of two former employees — and who are somehow communicating with the children.

Or are they? That's the question that has haunted literary scholars and readers since 1898, and it has never been definitively answered. Is the governess seeing real ghosts, or is she unraveling? Are the children innocent or complicit? Henry James built the ambiguity in deliberately, and it makes for the most extraordinary discussion.

Here's a piece of history I love: in the Victorian era, telling ghost stories at Christmas was a beloved tradition. Families would gather by the fire on Christmas Eve and frighten each other with tales of the supernatural. Henry James's novella opens with exactly that scene — a group sitting around a fire on Christmas Eve before one of them begins to tell this particular story. Reading The Turn of the Screw in December is, in the most literal sense, doing what it was meant for.

It's short — well under 100 pages — and as a classic from 1898, it's widely available for free on Project Gutenberg. Or pick up a beautiful print edition for just a few dollars. Either way, it is the perfect thing to read curled up somewhere quiet in December. GET A COPY

Ready to read with us?

The Halloween Book Club meets in our Facebook group, and we would love to have you. Whether you read every single book or just pop in for the ones that call to you, there's a place for you here. No pressure, no rules, just good scary books and a community of people who love Halloween as much as you do.

Previous
Previous

The Spooky Mom’s Mother’s Day Gift Guide

Next
Next

Inside the Spring 2026 Fun Size Issue