This recipe originally appeared on Patreon.
After sharing my caramel apple cup recipe inspired by treats I spotted at the 2025 Minnesota State Fair, I couldn't stop thinking about a second one I saw make the rounds on social media: a caramel apple seltzer.
If you know the fair, you know why this one caught my eye immediately. It's basically a caramel apple you can drink, and the caramel rim is exactly the kind of small, clever touch that makes fair food so much fun to recreate at home.
I took it a step further and threw in a caramel apple pop garnish.
So let's make it, plus I've got a full list of ways to make it your own — including a few grown-up twists.
How to make a caramel apple soda
What you need:
Apple soda
Caramel drizzle for the rim
Caramel apple pops
Sprinkles for the rim (optional)
To assemble, first rim your empty cup with caramel. Adding a dollop to a cutting board, then twisting the rim of the cup through the caramel is an easy way to add this. Next, twist the rim of the cup in any additions you want for decoration, like sprinkles or crushed candies.
Allow the caramel to solidify (5–10 mins in the freezer helps!), then add ice and your apple soda. Top with an unwrapped caramel apple pop, which you can also use as a stir stick, and enjoy immediately!
Want to customize your cup? Use these ideas!
🍸 Boozy twists
Add a splash of caramel vodka or vanilla vodka for an adult version.
Spike with spiced rum or apple whiskey for a cozy fall cocktail.
Mix in hard apple cider instead of soda for extra fizz + kick.
Top with a float of Irish cream for a creamy caramel vibe.
🥤 Dirty soda upgrades
Add a splash of cream, half & half, or vanilla creamer for richness.
Stir in flavored syrups like vanilla, pumpkin spice, or cinnamon.
Mix with a little Dr. Pepper, cream soda, or root beer for depth.
A dollop of whipped cream with caramel drizzle on top for a full dirty soda feel.
🍏 Fruity mix-ins
Toss in thin apple slices or pear slices to infuse flavor.
Add cherry juice or grenadine for a caramel apple "Shirley Temple."
Squeeze in a little lemon or lime juice to cut the sweetness.
Blend with cranberry juice for a caramel-apple-cranberry mocktail.
🍂 Spices & toppings
Sprinkle cinnamon or nutmeg over the top.
Add a cinnamon stick as a stirrer.
Garnish with a dried apple slice or a caramel candy.
Coat the rim with cinnamon sugar or crushed cookies after the caramel.
🎃 Festive extras
Serve with a candy apple skewer across the top of the glass.
Drop in a few candy corn pieces or a caramel cube for garnish.
Use black and orange straws for a spooky presentation.
Looking for more easy recipes to make?
I’ve got plenty of picks for fall. Try one of these: